Review: Best Aftershaves for Different Skin Types

When it comes to wet shaving, the aftershave you choose can be just as important as the razor or soap you use. A good aftershave soothes irritation, tightens pores, and provides that refreshing post-shave feel we all love.

But not all skin types are created equal, and neither are aftershaves.

At Shaving Time, we stock a carefully curated selection of aftershaves suited for all skin types. Whether you’re dealing with sensitivity, dryness, oiliness, or just want something that smells amazing, we’ve got something for you.

Here’s our guide to the best aftershaves for every skin type—featuring products we know and love.

🔵 For Sensitive Skin

Top Pick: Proraso After Shave Balm – Sensitive Skin (Green Tea & Oat)

• Why It Works: Alcohol-free and packed with soothing ingredients like oat extract and green tea, this balm calms irritation and reduces redness.
• Skin Feel: Cooling and gentle with a subtle, fresh scent.
• Best For: Men who experience post-shave burn, redness, or bumps.

👉 Also Try: Saponificio Varesino After Shave – Cubebe

Luxury meets function with added shea butter and witch hazel. Great for delicate skin needing hydration without sting.

🔴 For Dry Skin

Top Pick: Moon Soaps Aftershave Balm – Havana

• Why It Works: Rich and nourishing, this balm is infused with aloe, allantoin, and exotic oils to hydrate dry, tight skin after shaving.
• Skin Feel: Moisturising, non-greasy, and long-lasting.
• Best For: Men with flaky, tight, or weather-worn skin.

👉 Also Try Ariana & Evans Aftershave Splash – Pedro Fiasco

Though technically a splash, it contains skin-conditioning ingredients like aloe and glycerin, making it great for dry-prone skin types who prefer a liquid aftershave.

⚪ For Oily or Acne-Prone Skin

Top Pick: The Goodfellas' Smile Aftershave Splash – Sea Citrus

• Why It Works: Light and alcohol-based, this splash tightens pores, reduces excess oil, and adds a bright citrus scent without clogging pores.
• Skin Feel: Refreshing and invigorating with minimal residue.
• Best For: Men who deal with shiny skin, blemishes, or breakouts.

👉 Also Try: Barrister and Mann Aftershave – Seville

This alcohol splash is balanced with witch hazel and skin-soothing extracts. It helps tone oily skin while keeping it comfortable.

🟢 For Normal/Combination Skin

Top Pick: The Goodfellas' Smile Aftershave – Italian Barber

• Why It Works: A good all-rounder that delivers a classic barbershop scent with both alcohol and moisturising agents for balance.
• Skin Feel: Slight sting on application, followed by a smooth, clean finish.
• Best For: Guys who don’t suffer from major skin issues and want a daily driver with personality.

👉 Also Try: Phoenix Artisan Accoutrements Aftershaves

Innovative formulas with beautiful scents and ingredients like aloe, glycerin, and botanical extracts make these a standout for balanced skin types.

🌿 For a Natural Option

Top Pick: E&S Rasage Traditionnel Aftershave – Natural Line

• Why It Works: Made in France using mostly natural ingredients, this splash delivers performance without synthetic nasties.
• Skin Feel: Light, refreshing, and calming.
• Best For: Ingredient-conscious shavers who want performance and purity.

👉 Bonus Pick: Grave Before Shave Beard & Aftershave Tonic

Great dual-use product that tones the skin naturally with witch hazel and essential oils.

🪒 Final Thoughts

There’s no one-size-fits-all when it comes to aftershaves. The best choice depends on your skin type, lifestyle, and fragrance preference. Whether you’re looking for something to soothe sensitive skin or simply want to elevate your shaving routine with a scent that turns heads, we’ve got a bottle with your name on it.

💈 Shop our full collection of aftershaves here.

Still not sure which one to try? Reach out—we love helping fellow wet shaving enthusiasts find the perfect match.